The 5 Best Insurance Agents Around Grand County

Whether it’s snow damage to a roof, wildfire risk in the summer, or insuring the family truck that makes the Berthoud Pass climb every weekend, Grand County presents a unique set of insurance needs. Local residents don’t just want policies — they want agents who pick up the phone, know their first names, and understand the quirks of mountain life. This year’s Best of Grand contest highlighted insurance professionals who combine local experience with personal service.

Kurt Neibauer – State Farm Insurance

Based in Fraser, Kurt Neibauer has built a reputation as a go-to for auto, home, life, and business insurance across the county. As a State Farm agent, he offers access to national resources but keeps the focus squarely on local relationships. His office emphasizes fast responses, clarity in policy explanation, and a long-term approach to protecting what matters most. Clients appreciate his down-to-earth style and consistency, whether filing a claim or updating coverage.

Amber Holleman – Colorado Farm Bureau Insurance

Representing Colorado Farm Bureau Insurance in Kremmling, Amber Holleman focuses on personalized coverage that supports rural communities, agricultural businesses, and families. Her office handles farm and ranch policies, along with auto, home, and life insurance. Backed by a cooperative model and community-driven philosophy, Amber brings a grounded and approachable perspective to insurance, making sure clients understand both their risks and their protections.

Mike Periolat – Middle Park Agency

As one of the lead agents at Middle Park Agency in Granby, Mike Periolat offers comprehensive commercial and personal insurance services. His focus includes everything from property and casualty insurance to tailored business packages. With years of local experience and strong ties to the community, Mike helps clients navigate complex coverage decisions with confidence and clarity.

Stewart Goldenberg – Farmers Insurance

Stewart Goldenberg represents Farmers Insurance from his office in Winter Park, where he serves residents and business owners with a wide range of policy options. His approach prioritizes education and one-on-one consultation, helping customers choose plans that fit both their needs and budgets. Whether you’re new to the county or a longtime local, Stewart aims to make insurance feel less intimidating and more empowering.

Tyson Arnold – Middle Park Agency

Also part of the Middle Park Agency team, Tyson Arnold brings a strong customer-service ethic to his role. He focuses on matching clients with appropriate policies and making sure they stay informed as their needs change. Working alongside Mike Periolat, Tyson adds value through accessibility, attention to detail, and a shared commitment to serving Grand County with integrity.

Thanks, ChatGPT.